{"ok":true,"stdout":"{\n  \"review\": \"Adversarial Review\",\n  \"target\": {\n    \"mode\": \"working-tree\",\n    \"label\": \"working tree diff\",\n    \"explicit\": false\n  },\n  \"threadId\": \"01a168c7-5f67-7360-a391-548d65267ca2\",\n  \"context\": {\n    \"repoRoot\": \"/home/madsc/work/insuniverse-temp/.worktrees/admin-rbac\",\n    \"branch\": \"feat/admin-rbac\",\n    \"summary\": \"Reviewing 0 staged, 4 unstaged, and 18 untracked file(s).\"\n  },\n  \"codex\": {\n    \"status\": 0,\n    \"stderr\": \"\",\n    \"stdout\": \"{\\n  \\\"verdict\\\": \\\"needs-attention\\\",\\n  \\\"summary\\\": \\\"Do not accept the loss gate yet: a concrete unintended access loss passes check #9. The guard-path probe supports guard bypass only; the PRD log honestly records the narrower acceptance criterion, not restoration of /admin/admin.\\\",\\n  \\\"findings\\\": [\\n    {\\n      \\\"severity\\\": \\\"high\\\",\\n      \\\"title\\\": \\\"Ownership exemption hides failures on tenant-independent list endpoints\\\",\\n      \\\"body\\\": \\\"Every row uses id.tenant as its target, but I1 getAllAgencyList calls /admin/agencies/all without a target agency. sales-B legitimately receives its own agency through filtering, despite tenant=A in the fixture. In a read-only mutation test, changing that cell's ON result from 200/1 to either 403/- or 500/- still returned exit 0: LOSS=20 UNINTENDED=0 INTENDED_SCOPE=20 OWNER_NO_2XX=0. sales-A's successful request cannot establish that sales-B retained its own list access. The recorded tenant-switch negative test exercises ownership classification but misses this false acceptance.\\\",\\n      \\\"file\\\": \\\".claude/meta/2026-10-23-admin-rbac-m9c/owner-check-m9c.mjs\\\",\\n      \\\"line_start\\\": 94,\\n      \\\"line_end\\\": 101,\\n      \\\"confidence\\\": 1,\\n      \\\"recommendation\\\": \\\"Derive expected scope behavior per request: require successful filtered responses for global list endpoints, and allow ownership exemptions only for explicitly targeted out-of-scope resources with an expected denial status. Treat 5xx and transport failures as failures regardless of ownership. Add negative tests using the unchanged identities and mutated list responses.\\\"\\n    }\\n  ],\\n  \\\"next_steps\\\": [\\n    \\\"Fix the row-specific oracle and rerun check #9 with list-denial and server-error negative cases.\\\",\\n    \\\"Keep the /admin/admin schema-absence failure explicitly separate from the successful guard-path evidence.\\\"\\n  ]\\n}\",\n    \"reasoning\": []\n  },\n  \"result\": {\n    \"verdict\": \"needs-attention\",\n    \"summary\": \"Do not accept the loss gate yet: a concrete unintended access loss passes check #9. The guard-path probe supports guard bypass only; the PRD log honestly records the narrower acceptance criterion, not restoration of /admin/admin.\",\n    \"findings\": [\n      {\n        \"severity\": \"high\",\n        \"title\": \"Ownership exemption hides failures on tenant-independent list endpoints\",\n        \"body\": \"Every row uses id.tenant as its target, but I1 getAllAgencyList calls /admin/agencies/all without a target agency. sales-B legitimately receives its own agency through filtering, despite tenant=A in the fixture. In a read-only mutation test, changing that cell's ON result from 200/1 to either 403/- or 500/- still returned exit 0: LOSS=20 UNINTENDED=0 INTENDED_SCOPE=20 OWNER_NO_2XX=0. sales-A's successful request cannot establish that sales-B retained its own list access. The recorded tenant-switch negative test exercises ownership classification but misses this false acceptance.\",\n        \"file\": \".claude/meta/2026-10-23-admin-rbac-m9c/owner-check-m9c.mjs\",\n        \"line_start\": 94,\n        \"line_end\": 101,\n        \"confidence\": 1,\n        \"recommendation\": \"Derive expected scope behavior per request: require successful filtered responses for global list endpoints, and allow ownership exemptions only for explicitly targeted out-of-scope resources with an expected denial status. Treat 5xx and transport failures as failures regardless of ownership. Add negative tests using the unchanged identities and mutated list responses.\"\n      }\n    ],\n    \"next_steps\": [\n      \"Fix the row-specific oracle and rerun check #9 with list-denial and server-error negative cases.\",\n      \"Keep the /admin/admin schema-absence failure explicitly separate from the successful guard-path evidence.\"\n    ]\n  },\n  \"rawOutput\": \"{\\n  \\\"verdict\\\": \\\"needs-attention\\\",\\n  \\\"summary\\\": \\\"Do not accept the loss gate yet: a concrete unintended access loss passes check #9. The guard-path probe supports guard bypass only; the PRD log honestly records the narrower acceptance criterion, not restoration of /admin/admin.\\\",\\n  \\\"findings\\\": [\\n    {\\n      \\\"severity\\\": \\\"high\\\",\\n      \\\"title\\\": \\\"Ownership exemption hides failures on tenant-independent list endpoints\\\",\\n      \\\"body\\\": \\\"Every row uses id.tenant as its target, but I1 getAllAgencyList calls /admin/agencies/all without a target agency. sales-B legitimately receives its own agency through filtering, despite tenant=A in the fixture. In a read-only mutation test, changing that cell's ON result from 200/1 to either 403/- or 500/- still returned exit 0: LOSS=20 UNINTENDED=0 INTENDED_SCOPE=20 OWNER_NO_2XX=0. sales-A's successful request cannot establish that sales-B retained its own list access. The recorded tenant-switch negative test exercises ownership classification but misses this false acceptance.\\\",\\n      \\\"file\\\": \\\".claude/meta/2026-10-23-admin-rbac-m9c/owner-check-m9c.mjs\\\",\\n      \\\"line_start\\\": 94,\\n      \\\"line_end\\\": 101,\\n      \\\"confidence\\\": 1,\\n      \\\"recommendation\\\": \\\"Derive expected scope behavior per request: require successful filtered responses for global list endpoints, and allow ownership exemptions only for explicitly targeted out-of-scope resources with an expected denial status. Treat 5xx and transport failures as failures regardless of ownership. Add negative tests using the unchanged identities and mutated list responses.\\\"\\n    }\\n  ],\\n  \\\"next_steps\\\": [\\n    \\\"Fix the row-specific oracle and rerun check #9 with list-denial and server-error negative cases.\\\",\\n    \\\"Keep the /admin/admin schema-absence failure explicitly separate from the successful guard-path evidence.\\\"\\n  ]\\n}\",\n  \"parseError\": null,\n  \"reasoningSummary\": []\n}\n","stderr":"","durationMs":70806,"classification":"ok","blocking":false,"advisory":false}